Middle Cay offers a unique "bridge" between the total seclusion of a private island and the social vibrancy of Harbour Island (Briland). Located just a 5-minute boat ride from the world-famous Pink Sands Beach and Dunmore Town’s high-end boutiques, Middle Cay allows guests to dip into the social scene and retreat to their own 2-acre sanctuary in minutes. The island is impeccably maintained, featuring a working miniature lighthouse and two private docks (one with an automatic boat lift). With a focus on high-service "barefoot luxury," the rental includes a dedicated boat captain and daily housekeeping, making it an ideal choice for multi-family groups who want a private base with easy access to the Bahamas’ most iconic social hub.
THE ISLAND IN MOTION
The listing's own film — supplied with this listing · 27 sec
Accommodations & Design
The estate is split between two air-conditioned villas totalling 7 bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms, sleeping up to 17 guests. The Main House has four bedrooms: a master suite with a king bed, an ensuite bathroom with dual vanity and walk-in shower, and an oceanfront terrace; a second suite with two full beds and an ensuite rain shower; a third with two twin beds that convert to a king; and a fourth with a king bed and ensuite bathroom. Its open-plan living area includes a gourmet kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a dining table for 8, a living room with a large smart TV and satellite TV, and a private patio.
The Guest Cottage is a self-contained retreat with its own kitchen and living area and three further bedrooms: a king suite with ensuite rain shower and private balcony, a suite with two double beds and ensuite rain shower, and a child-friendly suite with a twin bunk and trundle bed. The villas open onto extensive terraces, an ocean-view swimming pool (heating is available as an optional upgrade), an outdoor shower, and a fire pit area for evening s'mores. A walkway winds around the entire island, and the island's own miniature lighthouse stands at its eastern point beside the dock.
Amenities & Inclusions
The Middle Cay experience is designed for effortless adventure. Use of a 22' Pursuit boat with a captain (fuel extra) is included for local transfers and snorkelling trips, and the captained 34' Intrepid is also at your disposal for exploring further afield; excursions to other destinations — the sandbars, Pig Beach, turtle cove, fishing trips and island hopping — are available at an additional charge. Also included are 3 kayaks, 2 paddleboards, a canoe, 3 underwater sea scooters, snorkelling gear, and fishing rods with bait.
Your stay includes a private boat captain, concierge support, and 4 hours of daily "light-touch" housekeeping. Available at extra cost are a private chef, butler service, grocery provisioning, laundry, extra housekeeping, babysitting and massages. A beach volleyball court, cornhole and beer pong are provided for guest use, and the island's two private docks — one with an automatic boat lift — mean guests can also arrive and tie up in their own boats.
How Private Is This Island?
Middle Cay is let to one party at a time: there are no other guests, and the island is strictly for the exclusive use of your party. Privacy here is a matter of geography honestly stated — the cay is small, at 2 acres, and it sits in the channel between Harbour Island and North Eleuthera, with the mainland shore across the water and boats passing through the channel. What you control completely is the island itself and the rhythm of the day: the boat captain runs you to Harbour Island in 5 minutes whenever you choose, so you can dine at a private table on your own island and be in a Briland club later the same evening, with the boat waiting to bring you back to your own quiet cay.
Getting There
Fly into North Eleuthera Airport (ELH), served by direct flights from Miami, Fort Lauderdale, Atlanta, Charlotte and New York, and by connections through Nassau. From the airport it is a 1.5-mile taxi ride to the Three Island Dock, where the island's boat picks you up — the team handles the transfer, and you can be relaxing on your own private island 15 minutes after landing. Once you are on the cay, the island's captain runs you to Harbour Island, 5 minutes away, at any time, included in the stay except for fuel.
PRICE — PUBLISHED RATE
From USD 2,969per night
Whole island · first 6 guests included · additional guests USD 150 per night
Holiday season from USD 6,999 per night · three-night minimum (five over the holidays)
Published rates · checked Nov 2026
